In a move that has sparked heated debate, the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) recently announced a name change intended to be more inclusive of transgender children and the broader LGBTQ community. As a former Boy Scout and Cub Scout, I find this change utterly ridiculous, particularly in light of the organization’s already existing efforts to promote inclusivity.
For over a century, the Boy Scouts have been a bastion of values such as leadership, community service, and personal development. The organization has long welcomed boys from various backgrounds, and in recent years, has opened its doors to girls, demonstrating a commitment to inclusivity. This decision was met with mixed reactions, but it marked a significant shift towards a more inclusive environment. Now, the proposed name change seeks to further embrace diversity by explicitly including transgender children and members of the LGBTQ community.
However, this move raises several questions and concerns. First, the inclusion of girls in the Boy Scouts was a substantial change that many argued diluted the traditional essence of the organization. While the integration aimed to provide equal opportunities for all children, it also blurred the lines that defined the organization for so long. The new name change seems to follow a similar path, potentially eroding the unique identity of the Boy Scouts.
Secondly, the BSA has already taken significant steps to be inclusive. The organization has policies in place that prevent discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. Scouts and leaders who identify as LGBTQ have been welcomed into the fold for years. Thus, the argument that a name change is necessary to promote inclusivity seems redundant. Furthermore, the focus on altering the name appears to be a superficial solution to a deeper issue.
True inclusivity comes from the actions and policies within the organization, not merely from its name. By concentrating on a name change, the BSA risks alienating members who feel that the core values and traditions of the Boy Scouts are being overshadowed by an excessive emphasis on political correctness.
Kacy Benefield is an accomplished historian who challenges not just what is being taught but those who are teaching it. Born in Los Angeles, California, a loving son, brother, husband and father who does not make the news but only reports the truth. Benefield is also the co-host of the show Better Benefield.
I wholeheartedly agree.